Will try write my suggestions without all arguments at first, i'm not sure it's worth to type all, just want to give some tips for Inno games.
1. Logs of activity like GvG has! Plus detailed players activity log where can show how much player did total/today or last successful fights/neg. f.e. Negs - 10, total fights - 100, today - 15, last: 30 min ago.
2. Rights panel for guild leaders. It has same based rights as founders/leaders, but it could be more flexible like: can't start new battle, can't finish, can't destroy/build, can't fight. It can be managed individually by leader.
3. Attrition costs equivalent. f.e: 30 attr and I have 200%/200% opponents, when have 60 attr - 751%/751%, 90attr - 1,740%/1,740%.
Basically most of fighters have ~500% attack bonus and easy can go up tp 60 attr, but if you have double attack bonus (1k%), that is 5 times much harder to achieve than 500%, you do only 10-15 more fights than 500% can do. That should grow not so drastically. I see cap now changed from 1740/1740 to 12000%/12000%. And you have it only at 150 attrition level.
3. Watermarked sector numbering like: B2T, C3V. No need to click, easier to find sectors.
4. Leader(could be managed from rights panel) who could flag 1 sector where to attack. Now players fighting and should always check msgs threads, some never check and do wrong things, hard to control, etc.
5. Lack use of medals. It could costs for buildings and for instant build also. Instant build could be like 200 diamonds* or 500k* medals (in diamond league) 300k* in platinum and 200k* in gold. *These amounts for example.
6. We invited new player from LMA age, now NPC ask us for LMA goods everywhere, we can't afford to buy it, it cost 2-3k each for buildings and whole guild suffer. All session can get wrong. It could be chosen from 2 types of goods to be more flexible. All in all costs are too high. 6k SAM age goods for building? not too much?
7. Reset at evening, e.g.21p.m, not at midnight. It could bring more live fun.
8. Should be a way to defend your sectors, it would be more live game. But here have no suggests how it should look like.
9. Opponents should be from other worlds, we have 3rd session with the same opponents and looks like will have them forever. No more stronger guilds at the same world to kick up/down and to be fair - It's already boring. You know what to expect, know others possibilities, know tactics even can deal if you have friends. Impossible to talk could make more fun.
10. Session too long, think it should be like GE. 6 days of fights and 1 day to rest. Shorter session, less difference between VPs -> more fun with some extra moves and extra gain. Then use of goods/buildings can be more valuable.
11. Only 1 statue of honor? nothing more? Personally for me rewards from it also not worth to build. Why not buildings who can give lower attrition, more attack and more defence, or even GB with these bonuses? Virgo, Gazer, etc...
12. Guild rewards difference not equivalent. 470k power for 2nd and 400k for 5th?
13. Guilds matching should depend on amount of players. 70-80 guilds, 60-70, etc. Now 30-50 players guild can do nothing vs 70-80. It could be even more powerful, but with this progressive attrition you can't win. 30 players guild with 1k attack % can't beat 60 players guild with 300% attack, it's ridiculous.
The longer you wait without logical updates, the faster people lose motivation.
Will try to answer on all your questions/sugestions, some are really good but asked already dozens of times.
1. good one, you maybe ask to many details but good one, asked by others including me at least 10 times.
2. good one, again you ask maybe to many details but yes, good one, asked by others including me at least 10 times.
3. they changed this so that weaker players can do more and stronger players can do less, its on my personal damage and damage of my guild but i kinda understand why they did it, with atrition maxed on 1750% i could do infinite number of battles so to conclude, that change was on my personal damage and damage of my guild since we have a lot of strong hiters but good for game in general
3. (i am repeating 3 since you also have 3x2) nobody didnt sugest that and that is ok idea, i am afraid just that this would cause even more problems in GvG (maps are freezing all the time anyway and few more issues but map freezing atm biggest one).
4. also good idea but also sugested many times by many players including me.
5. kinda like idea but i think inno wont take it especialy now while players spend a lot of diamonds on GbG
6. i am intrested what is criteria how game pick goods for buildings, is it really at random, or is it by players wich doing attacks or what is criteria wich kind of goods will be picked? ˙( question is @mods)
7. against this big time, maybe it shouldnt be midnight but for sure it shouldnt be same time as calc or around that time, at least 2 hours + or -
8. sugested few times, also nobody didnt have precise idea how to do it, maybe puting troops in to increase number of battles but then it is to similar to GvG and no other ideas from me at least not atm.
9. BIG, HUGE +++ but also sugested by many players lot of times.
10. i think current times are ok so against this one for sure
11. how you mean 'only one statue of honour?' ??? you can build as many as you like but statue of honour should be fixed, atm it gives bonus only for farmers, why not change it a bit that it give some attack precentage also so that it give bonus to fighters also???
12. I also think diference is to small but there is one good point, they did it how lowest one would be better than 1st one in lower league so that all try to move up in leagues.
13. i am in guild with 57 players and atm we are beating 3 guilds wich play in team against us, that is 210 players vs 57 and atm i dont see problem in that... problem is that you have players and 'players' and i prefer 50 players over 200 'players' and if guild is made up from 'players' it will drop league and will be balanced in next round... all this will be fixed in few rounds of GbG but then you will fight always same guilds if they dont make this competition competition between the worlds.