1. Forge Questers!

    Join the contest for a chance to win 1,000 diamonds Read all about it here.
    Dismiss Notice
  2. A Few Good Mods!

    Check out the various positions we have to offer here.
    Dismiss Notice

  3. Fall Event 2019

    On your marks. Get set. Bake! This year, the Fall Bake Off makes its return to your city in style!
    For detailed information, please click here!
    Dismiss Notice
  4. Forge Cafe

    Head to our Forge Cafe, ask a question, or have a chat. It's the perfect place for you to pull up a chair and learn more about the game and the forum here.
    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice

Guild Battlegrounds

Discussion in 'Announcement Discussions' started by Lady Marlena, May 20, 2019.

  1. Lady Marlena

    Lady Marlena FoE Team Community Manager

    Mar 16, 2016
    So did we which we attached to the actual announcement so they wouldn't get lost. It is also a work in progress as questions are being added at a fairly quick pace from all servers, so I'll be doing my best to keep that piece updated. So do check there first , in case I've answered it (possibly not yet :) ) Feedback on all servers so far has been great and a lot of really good questions are being asked as well as suggestions for it.

    our page
  2. shad23

    shad23 Tsar

    Mar 30, 2015
  3. war of the worlds

    war of the worlds Private

    Feb 17, 2017
    Could one of the rewards be on GBG the reversal of cost of FP's for coin that would make me very happy :-)
    Mikk likes this.
  4. coco87

    coco87 Private

    May 10, 2018
    I like the fact that negotiation is an option. I personally find the fighting side of this game somewhat tedious and boring. I usually choose negotiation over battle when it's an option (and I'm not low on goods). I think this opens the feature up to a wider set of players, which is good.

    I do think attrition should apply to negotiation. Both DC and GE have varying levels of negotiation cost/difficulty. I would think this could easily be done here, where your attrition value (from both fighting and negotiating) determines the cost/difficulty of the next negotiation.

    I also agree that attrition is something that should decay over time, rather than reset at a specific time of day. That would add an element of strategy around attrition: Do I fight or negotiate now? Or do I wait an hour our 2 to increase my chances of being successful?

    I do look forward to seeing this implemented.
  5. Vesiger

    Vesiger General

    Jan 2, 2016
    People have been questioning the defence system - it sounds rather like the 'Guild Wars' that were added to another online game that I play, Creature Quest. In that game every guild gets given a set of buildings each of which carries a boost; you can garrison armies in buildings but you can't defend them in real time. The war consists of guilds attacking one another's buildings. You score points for damaging buildings, and more for being the one to contribute the 'death blow', and these accumulated points can be spent to raise the level of your own buildings. But every time another guild scores a death blow on one of your buildings, it goes down a level again (and the bonus reduces).
    So the only way to raise the level of your buildings is to score enough points attacking other guilds in order to promote them faster than your opponents can knock them down...
  6. BruteForceAttack

    BruteForceAttack Sergeant

    Jan 1, 2018
    Is the Negotiating part C-map way or GE way?
    anyempire likes this.
  7. CaptainJacksparrow

    CaptainJacksparrow FoE Team Ingame Moderator

    Oct 6, 2015
    good point, there's a big difference between the 2 .
    anyempire likes this.
  8. Lady Marlena

    Lady Marlena FoE Team Community Manager

    Mar 16, 2016
    I've forwarded the question :)

    It is :)
  9. BruteForceAttack

    BruteForceAttack Sergeant

    Jan 1, 2018
    "To take a province, every guild member can click on an eligible province and either perform a fight or a negotiation. These fights and negotiations will always match the era of the player who performs it, allowing every guild member to participate in a feasible manner!"

    Will the eligible province always have one wave fights or could it include 2 waves?

    How many armies per province? 1 set/ 2 sets or will it be 8 sets (GVG)?

    What happens if multiple players (same guild or different guilds) try and take same province?

    Can a guild simultaneously attack multiple provinces?

    Unlike GVG there is no need to move HQ correct? A guild can keep on expanding their territory?
    Vesiger and anyempire like this.
  10. Lady Marlena

    Lady Marlena FoE Team Community Manager

    Mar 16, 2016

    Questions forwarded thank you :)
    anyempire likes this.
  11. Michael K.

    Michael K. Major-General

    Sep 15, 2012
    1. How is this sustainable?? If one Guildie is attacking by himself - troops are gonna dry up pretty fast. Is this just 'GvG for Mobile Users.'? As far as I can tell, your still gonna need several people attacking at one time, it's just that you don't necessarily need a 'Trusted' to place the siege.
    2. Does the cost per province go up in the ridiculous manner as GvG? Good for the large Guilds, I suppose.
    . . . mk
  12. joesoap

    joesoap Major-General

    Feb 17, 2013
    When a battleground ends, guilds may obtain various rewards which depend on placement:

    Prestige Points for the ranking
    Guild Power
    Each member will get fragments for a completely new, upgradeable building that will provide Guild Power, Guild Treasury Goods and Forge Points

    i think that the last individual fragment part should be calculated for each player & how much they do as opposed to every1 in the guild getting the same reward so if players do nothing & contribute nothing they should get nothing back
    Ceban, Vesiger, KDS-33 and 3 others like this.
  13. Michael K.

    Michael K. Major-General

    Sep 15, 2012
    Will Guilds have a minimum amount of members required for GB, or can one-person guilds partake? The structure seems to indicate a minimum membership needed, unless there are hundreds of battlegrounds created for the single player guilds.
    . . . mk
    Last edited: May 22, 2019
    Lugh Longarm, Tombo224 and Emberguard like this.
  14. TheKingOfKool

    TheKingOfKool Brigadier-General

    Mar 1, 2016
    Sounds Like fun.

    Be sure to fix/not introduce the release and retake issue that GvG has.

    Guilds release sectors just before the reset clock - at less than 1 minute before reset.
    And then they can retake that at same sector in just a few minutes - right after the new reset begins.

    If a guild releases a sector, they are not allowed to retake that sector for 24 hours. but the flaw allows it.
    This a major flaw in the game!
    KDS-33 and Emberguard like this.
  15. Blitz Epidemic

    Blitz Epidemic Sergeant

    Sep 19, 2014
    I'll repeat myself again, the more activities you add to this game, which quickly become mandatory if you don't want to be left in the dust, the more players will continue to abandon it. Quit adding more and more time consuming stuff, start adding time conserving stuff. You will lose your most active players if this keeps up.
    KDS-33 and JoanTheLovingOne like this.
  16. lastwarrior1955

    lastwarrior1955 Chief Warrant Officer

    Jul 25, 2014
    This BM is a superb Idea, at last a guild will be rewarded for what the guild does against another guild and it should be possible to stop a guild sending out ghost guilds, alleyluya.
    Now there should be no pacts between guilds and everybody should be rewarded for attacking ALL guilds on their map, we do not need any collusion at all.
    I wish lol.
    Bring it on, oh and as for the current GvG get it binned and save yourself an awful lot of hassle.
    Well done
  17. Tombo224

    Tombo224 Private

    May 22, 2019
    I think this is a great idea. What I would like to know is will the Support Pool which you get from Obs and some others, count towards this Guild Battlegrounds (GBG)? In our guild we have worked hard to get our Obs levels higher, and if all it does is count towards GvG (which whilst still there - it will be diluted by this new feature), the Support Pool will be less useful than it is now. I hope it has some impact on GBG. Thanks.
  18. Pikeman07

    Pikeman07 Private

    Feb 12, 2016
    Nikos from Greece,Athens exist my play.
    New locations always excited.Peaceful also interesting ideas exist.
    Scenario with fixed size troops participate player and guilds sum No units,also interesting.
    Location use optional past epoch troops of city,personal challenge,nice idea.
    Hope got new values or unique stock collection values or goods too.
  19. Sanctillius Prime

    Sanctillius Prime Private

    Mar 28, 2017
    Like previous posters have written, the attrition should ideally reduce over time. If it resets at a specific point in time, we could just end up with another GvG reset battle fest with few people playing at any other time.

    Looks interesting though.
  20. Rochebord

    Rochebord Private

    May 22, 2019
    Will guild battlegrounds be available to guilds with one member?