so you can see what people do in GE , GvG, treasury donations etc... - so how is being able to see what people do in GbG any different ?
someone seems to think that people will be punished for doing things in GbG that don't fir in with the guild's plan, rather than someone having a private conversation with the players who behave like loose cannons and educating them
this objection seems to be more about somebody's personal agenda and maybe a run in with a guild founder elsewhere, rather than anything to do with benefits or disadvantages to guilds / players
the simple solution is to go and form your own guild if you don't fit in where you are, then you can do whatever you like
some guilds have rules which the guild members are expected to follow, if they don't fit in they are kicked
if you want a guild run on the anarchy principle form your own
you aren't forced to be in a guild you don't like, and no guild is forced to have you as a member
(as an aside: one of the people most against this idea of being able to see what people are doing in GbG has in their guild profile a message saying all guild members must do 64 GE each week or they will be kicked) - seems a bit odd doesn't it ?