possibility to plunder military buildings

[Agent327]

if it works then do it am just tired of seeing that kind of def and yes that would be a way to force players to put better def , just kicking the idea box around here to find a way to solve the problem thanks for input

There is no problem. There is only something you do not like seeing and you still do not seem to comprehend that players do not put 2 spearfighters in their defence. It is what you see when they have put NOTHING in their defence. You can not force players to put anything there if they do not want to. Force me to put 8 units from my era there and I will give you 8 rogues.

 

[Shad23]

If you are playing from mobile phone or tablet you should forget about winning the tournament

FoE should correct this because it's unfair for those users just trying to get a few problems fixed here with my idea

 

[DeletedUser96901]

Force me to put 8 units from my era there and I will give you 8 rogues.

actually rogues are not from your era

try it in attack (against 2 spearfighters )
and you will see that it counts to no era and for that reason you won't get any tower points

 

[Agent327]

actually rogues are not from your era

try it in attack (against 2 spearfighters )
and you will see that it counts to no era and for that reason you won't get any tower points

Go to army management, select your age and see what you get.

I do not need to try them in attack. This is about defence and defence I do not get tower points anyhow.

 

[DeletedUser96901]

Go to army management, select your age and see what you get.

go to army management. select bronze age and see what you get

with that logic rogues are bronze age

I do not need to try them in attack.

at least then you would know to which era rogues really belong
to none

This is about defence and defence I do not get tower points anyhow.

this is about units of your era and not about what you can select in the army management when selecting an era


so if a rules will be implemented: only defense units of your era then that excludes rogues

 

[DeletedUser107476]

Reason :
if there where possibility of plundering military buildings like rogue hideouts more players would plunder because that way they would not have to produce those military units it would be a new way to get units for GE or GvG

Guild Expeditions already produces troops for you to use in Guild Expeditions.

Proposal:
i think that the possibility to plunder military buildings like rogue hideouts might be a good idea
would like this to be applyed only on citys where owner has not placed a better DA then the default DA
because it is a painfull sight everytime i see 2 spearfighters as DA

You want players to place full DA's and your solution is to take troops from them?
InnoGames also will not go half measure if they allowed barracks to plundered it would be all barracks no matter what the DA is.

Balance/Abuse Prevention :
i don't think there would be abuse if the neighborhoods are well balanced

The abuse is simple, this just makes the strongest players in the hood stronger.

-1

 

[Prinza the Hunter]

-1

It has some appeal but is too open to abuse and gives more powerful players an exponential advantage.

Perhaps it might be considered for a Great Building: a percentage chance to gain one of the defeated units after winning a battle, with a much lower chance if the defeated army is of a lower age.

 

[Agent327]

go to army management. select bronze age and see what you get

with that logic rogues are bronze age

No, with that logic they are all ages.

at least then you would know to which era rogues really belong
to none

Or to all.

this is about units of your era and not about what you can select in the army management when selecting an era

Why not? If I am on GvG I can select rogues on every era, so they belong to that era.

so if a rules will be implemented: only defense units of your era then that excludes rogues

No, it includes rogues, cause they will show up on the army management of my era. And drummers. And color guards.

 

[DeletedUser107476]

No, it includes rogues, cause they will show up on the army management of my era. And drummers. And color guards.

No it would not. Same as quests that state recruit units from your era or the era below, do not include rogues, drummers or color guards.

 

[Agent327]

No it would not. Same as quests that state recruit units from your era or the era below, do not include rogues, drummers or color guards.

Recruiting is something else. Once again, if I fight in GvG say Modern, I need to use units from that age and I can include rogues.

You can argue this both ways.

 

[Shad23]

It has some appeal but is too open to abuse and gives more powerful players an exponential advantage.

not if neighborhoods are well balanced

 

[Agent327]

not if neighborhoods are well balanced

How do you plan to take care of that?

 

[Shad23]

balanc

How do you plan to take care of that?

balancing the neighborhoods is dev 's job not mine just giving ideas here

 

[DeletedUser107476]

balancing the neighborhoods is dev 's job not mine just giving ideas here

There have been a few attempts at doing so and even devs will admit there is no perfect way of making the hoods completely balanced.

 

[Agent327]

balanc

balancing the neighborhoods is dev 's job not mine just giving ideas here

So basically you come up with an idea with a lot of problems and devs have to fix that. I am sure that will work.

 

[Shad23]

So basically you come up with an idea with a lot of problems and devs have to fix that. I am sure that will work.

dev 's are already working on balancing the neighborhoods , and neighborhoods ain't the problem here

 

[Shad23]

balancing the neighborhoods

was already a problem well befor my idea

 

[Agent327]

was already a problem well befor my idea

So that makes your idea to open to abuse and since that can not be fixed it ca go into the wastebin.

 

[DeletedUser]

might be an idea to apply this only on citys that have 2 spearfighters as def , because the main reason of my idea is to stop players from leaving only 2 spearfighters as def

That being the case, I would suggest scrapping the original idea and suggest that a pop-up screen appear after a player investigates Military Tactics with some info about defensive army and a button to go to army setup. This pop-up would appear as long a the player has not changes the default defensive army (sort of what now happens when you're guild-less).

 

[DeletedUser105579]

so
-1

the idea is an abuse
5 neighbors plunder each other daily
and at the end of the week they have 28 unattached units from one barrack


think again about it

-1 for this reason. Well said.