DeletedUser96901
that is the short time view- The rewards seem very high and close together. Not that we wouldn't want them, but when one can get >100,000 guild points for doing nothing while those who dump large amounts of goods into it for perhaps 30% more reward then we fear will it quickly lead to idleness and stale matches before the end of the 11 day period, because not many are willing to pay that much attention for only a little difference in the rewards.
you should look it as long time feature
guild who wins goes up into a better league (maybe not after the first season) and win higher rewards
guild doing nothing goes down. and in the league below the rewards are much lower
(and doing nothing is also a little bit wrong: they did something. they reached that league. ok in the first season that was be doing other things: GE&GVG. but later guilds earn to be in a league. and if they do little they won't be there for long)