Emberguard
Legend
@Behelzebhu the mafia win condition was:
You win when the Mafia have an unavoidable majority
Because you couldn't get a majority lynch without Jade going against their win condition and they had a kill Mafia could still achieve their win. Whereas you had to eliminate all of the mafia and didn't have any way to do so with only one town left.
Even if their win condition had been identical to yours (requiring to eliminate everyone who was town), they'd still have the means to complete it while town would not in a 1 v 1 situation
IF it had been a version with a 1-shot Vigilante (Town with kill) then it'd have been a draw as both would eliminate each other.
You win when the Mafia have an unavoidable majority
Because you couldn't get a majority lynch without Jade going against their win condition and they had a kill Mafia could still achieve their win. Whereas you had to eliminate all of the mafia and didn't have any way to do so with only one town left.
Even if their win condition had been identical to yours (requiring to eliminate everyone who was town), they'd still have the means to complete it while town would not in a 1 v 1 situation
IF it had been a version with a 1-shot Vigilante (Town with kill) then it'd have been a draw as both would eliminate each other.