While it might be useful to some unestablished guilds, it simply would be nice to have a choice and not have a nuisance forced upon us.
If it could be adminned, renamed etc it might very well be useful. Otherwise it's useless and taking up space. In fact if we could choose to pin certain number of threads and admin them ourselves that would be even more useful!
Our threads are very organised and require specific headings and we're not lazy in having to admin them, we're happy to put in the effort so we can customise them to suit our needs.
And for those who say nothing will please any of us, you're wrong. There's plenty very pleasing about recent updates on messaging system. Just not this one.
I find the reason to have ppl outside of the guild which requires to be part of all your guild affairs unsound, if so, they should just join your guild. Its rather a private preference and cant be a valid argument against the new feature plus, the message system offers a way to do it, which you already have in use
You couldn't be more wrong. Sister guilds or closely allied guilds can help each other in trading, aiding etc and often friend each other and can assist in each other's progress. They can also get to know one another better through joint threads, thus making the game more community friendly and a lot more fun!
Limiting this, is limiting the broader social aspect of this game.