Not a Bug: Incorrect global ranking

[Atokirina]

Username: Atokirina (1974322)
Flash Player version: 1.271.c01a81a99c (05.12.2023 11:03) ~ Not Flash Player though
Operating system: Windows 10, Android 13
Browser & Version: Chrome/120.0.0.0
Viewport size: 1920x937

Description:

Incorrect ranking in the global ranking: at the beginning of a new championship, guilds with the same number of league points are not sorted according to the number of championships won (when no victory points have been achieved yet - global ranking incorrect for 3 days and 1 hour per championship).

Browser​

• Ranking

Spoiler: Screenshot

App​

• Ranking

Spoiler: Screenshot

Reproduction steps:
1. Not reproducible anymore (except when the championship has ended).

Further feedback:

This couldn't have been intended; the developers likely didn't account for the period when no victory points can be earned. It shouldn't be the case that a guild with the most championship wins temporarily drops from the top spot (until the guild secures the most victory points again in the next championship). During this grace period, the amount of championships won should be taken into account when league points are equal.

Current ranking priority order: League Points > Victories > Victory Points > Guild Level

To resolve the incorrect ranking during the grace period, this should be adjusted to: Leauge Points > Victories > Victory Points > Championship Wins > Guild Level

 

[Piet1963]

Firstly I want to thank Inno for the new GBG set up. It give fights for every member of the guild and there is most of the time sectors to attack. However there is a loophole in this system and some guilds abuse it and it pull the ranking of guilds scew . Because of the two tier system in the diamond league of 1000 and 975 points some guilds play a yoyo effect and score a victory in the lower league and thus earn a lot of points and also good ranking . In the previous season there was on guild in our group of eight guilds that had 3 victories through the up and down effect that in the whole season only held their home sector , no other sector at all. So it seems that there is two or three guilds that fight for top spot and some guilds tries hard for the last spot . Was that the idea with the new GBG . If I may put a suggestion on the table it would be to separate the 1000 point and 975 point groups for the all the seasons of the new round and at the end of the 7/8 seasons and then swop those who must go up en those that must go down .

 

[Kyrael]

Firstly I want to thank Inno for the new GBG set up. It give fights for every member of the guild and there is most of the time sectors to attack. However there is a loophole in this system and some guilds abuse it and it pull the ranking of guilds scew . Because of the two tier system in the diamond league of 1000 and 975 points some guilds play a yoyo effect and score a victory in the lower league and thus earn a lot of points and also good ranking . In the previous season there was on guild in our group of eight guilds that had 3 victories through the up and down effect that in the whole season only held their home sector , no other sector at all. So it seems that there is two or three guilds that fight for top spot and some guilds tries hard for the last spot . Was that the idea with the new GBG . If I may put a suggestion on the table it would be to separate the 1000 point and 975 point groups for the all the seasons of the new round and at the end of the 7/8 seasons and then swop those who must go up en those that must go down .

Thanks for your comments, but they may be better placed in the GBG feedback thread rather than this bug report
GBG Feedback Thread

 

[Piet1963]

Thx .