Yes, guild members will see all your trades with a guild symbol next to them, whether they are "guild-only" or "global". Your neighbours on the other hand, should only be able to see the trades that you set up "globally".
Looks like no bug to me, so sending this topic to that section
I do not agree, i think
it is a bug, i suppose game developer should modified it
1. First of all, guild-only and global trade offered by a guild member, should be able be viewed by all guild members
so game mod. say, it can be viewed by all guild member, i do agree that part
2. However, they are 2 different kind of trade, game developer should add something showing which 1 is guild -only and which 1 is global
why ??
this is a game
player play differently
Inside a guild, we are fair to each other by exchange goods, we are helping each other
We place the trade to help guild member , and he place the trade to help me, we are both equal
Inside a guild, we exchange goods with ratio 1: 1 for same age goods
e.g.
(a) 10 lumber to exchange with 10 stone, no cheating, we call fair-trade
(b) if some guild member need thigns urgently, he can post 15 lumber exchange with 10 stone, that is fine as he are willing to give more to get urgent demand. he is offerign advantage. we accept this kind of trade.
(c) if a guild member offering 10 lumber and asking 15 stone, which we all considered a un-fair trade. It contra-dict a guild function ( group together and fair to each member inside a guild ). Those trader , strip other guild member benefits. we need to impose punishment , warnign and expel .
Outisde the guild, guild member is doing a business game, he can place fair and unfair trade in market. It is totally at player discretion. He is playing a additional part of the game, a trading game too. We will not interference his business plan, He get additional goods, it is totally his game fun. We will not stop it.
However
the current display about those 2 trades
"guild only trade" and "global trade" has cause confusion> Guild leader and admin -guild member cannot identify whehter
that guild member has void guild rules < as far as i know, many guild has imposed fair trade inside guild, some guild member say "expel" if there is unfair trade >. This make Guild leader cannot control that part of his guild ..it is all becos game developer do not display those 2 kind of trade properly.
I have do the test
i post same trades, 1 is "Guild onlY" and other "Global"
i can see : "your current offer", i can identify which 1 is guild only becos it has a guild symbol attaching to it beside the "rate"
but our guild member see both trade are the same , no difference
< in fact, when guild member click "guild only button", both trades appear with no difference, no sign of telling which 1 is gloal and which is guild-only >
I would say, It is a bug,
that guild symbol (as seen in "your current offer" should also view by our guild members, but it is missing
if the developer say, no such symbol
i would strognly suggest developer add that feature back, it help guild leader to manage their guild
