Guild bank - Because banks are everywhere

[DeletedUser17]

Thank you foryour posts, especially to mungiu for bringing this idea to the forum. I will Pass this on.

 

[DeletedUser]

Update, added point #8. This will make the end game look more meaningful to a player. He will no longer feel remorse for not being able to invest those 10 F.P. into something.

 

[DeletedUser]

how about making it just like a bank... the top players in guild borrow the money/supplies to the less fortunate and then demand interest ... if they cant pay it back on time the big players hire a site bailiff to collect a few buildings.... just a joke but i like it actually haha :p

 

[DeletedUser7719]

You really expect interest Franky? I thought you wanted to help the guild, lol

 

[DeletedUser]

how about making it just like a bank... the top players in guild borrow the money/supplies to the less fortunate and then demand interest ... if they cant pay it back on time the big players hire a site bailiff to collect a few buildings.... just a joke but i like it actually haha :p

I recommend you read through the first comments and see what your idea might generate, there is a reason why the system is complicated.
The reason is: Multi-accounts must be dead!

Adding interest... too much math for so simple operations which will only superficially influence the guild Economy system.

 

[DeletedUser]

at the first read of this idea i thought no way as it allows trades between players (indirectly) and of a way of passing wealth , but it could work if guilds could build guild buildings that henhence the full guild , like build a cathederal that gives every player 100 happiness thats in the guild ,it would be expensive to build and have a upkeep
or build a guild workshop that allows every member of guild to employ 1 man to enhance a production output for 12 hours on one of his buildings of his choice (of course at a slight cost ),as these buildings would need to be built from the guild bank .
this would make the guilds work together for something that helps everyone in guild and get some guild communuity going.
but i can only see a guild bank working if it is to allow the guild to grow and not for the help of individual players (ie loans ect )
as i see theres alot of scope in this i will be happy to throw some more of those types of ideas out about it (if people think its a good idea)

 

[DeletedUser7719]

Welcome to the forums jlb1jlb1! your suggestions may be considered, thanx for replying

 

[DeletedUser]

i will be happy to throw some more of those types of ideas out about it (if people think its a good idea)

Please do! Criticize my idea as you wish, it will help me since it is hard for me to find it's week points because i elaborated it and have a subjective view.

P.S. As far as it goes i think my idea does not involve the help of individual players except for the F.P. (which can only be use for a lousy trade offer from time to time) but if you think it is a bad point please let me know why

 

[DeletedUser]

i by no means criticize you mungui as the idea of a guild bank could be a very big thing if its taken in the right direction.

 

[DeletedUser]

I recommend you read through the first comments and see what your idea might generate, there is a reason why the system is complicated.
The reason is: Multi-accounts must be dead!

Adding interest... too much math for so simple operations which will only superficially influence the guild Economy system.

i know dude im only joking with ya, but back to the subject at hand, i like the idea.

 

[DeletedUser]

Update 11/23/2012 - In this update i introduced a way in which Guild Banks can be integrate with Great Buildings. This update was worked on together with another forum user. I suspect he wishes to stay anonymous for now, he will declare himself in here if he will want to.

Feedback is welcomed!

 

[DeletedUser]

Updated all content to make the idea more easy to understand. Eliminated allot of useless features and introduced a couple of new fundamentals.

 

[DeletedUser7719]

Some comments:
1) You spelled "tire 1"
2) I'm still a little confused how this stops multi accounting (when it comes to guild banks)

 

[DeletedUser1094]

Until the next game-update has been reviled, it's really not much I have to say... and maybe why Mods and staff in generally hasn't commented this Bank-idea of yours. You have really put a lot of effort into perfecting your idea... but I'm afraid that, a lot of it, is based on your own assumptions of, what's to come, and those assumptions might not be right. It would be better, to propose ideas to current game-issues and then alter the idea later on, to comply with eventually future game-updates.

Tokens can only be used for building Guild Related buildings

At the moment, the only Guild-related "building" is the Guild-flag, and I have no knowledge of others to come. There might be plans for the future, but of that, I don't know...

I need some feed back for that however.

There are some issues about your "Great Buildings", that we simply can't comment on right now. But it shouldn't be very long...

I hope the people will at least read this till end

tl;dr :p
Nah, just kidding... I read every post in here...

 

[DeletedUser]

Edit----------

I guess there is no more point in developing this ideas after the current update.

Thank you all for all your help, this was a fine experience!