Hi OVERTYPE Lady Marlena sorted it for me had to remove a rogue from my attacking army apparently but since then have had many battles on the AF 3 province map and haven't had the same issue , however one of my guildies hasn't been able to log in, keeps getting a message that she has an outdated version of the game which I think must be a glitch in an update because I have been playing the same version of the game for over 2 years