Nymegan
Private
Straight up I don't like the extra "attempts" as a reward in guild expeditions. Currently I fight my way through and don't need this reward. I would rather something of benefit to my city rather than something that only aids me in the GE.
If I was negotiating I can see its value. However, as luck would have it I have won all the 1st level 2 attempt rewards for the last few weeks and at least one 4 attempt reward as well. Perhaps the answer is to reduce the percentage chances to something like 5% instead of 45%.
Alternatively have different rewards depending on whether you fight or negotiate... But I can see that would mean more coding work, so isn't a short term viable fix.
If I was negotiating I can see its value. However, as luck would have it I have won all the 1st level 2 attempt rewards for the last few weeks and at least one 4 attempt reward as well. Perhaps the answer is to reduce the percentage chances to something like 5% instead of 45%.
Alternatively have different rewards depending on whether you fight or negotiate... But I can see that would mean more coding work, so isn't a short term viable fix.