DeletedUser102348
+1
-
Dear forum reader,
To actively participate in our forum discussions or to start your own threads, in addition to your game account, you need a forum account. You can REGISTER HERE!
Please ensure a translation into English is provided if your post is not in English and to respect your fellow players when posting.
-
We are looking for you! Always wanted to join our Support or Forum Team? We are looking for enthusiastic moderators!
Take a look at our recruitment page for more information and how you can apply:
- Status
DeletedUser14502
AHA you are actually asking for the filters not the whole thing if that is the case then +1 for sure (It sounded like you were asking for the whole feature and those of us who aren't founders don't know the screen).
DeletedUser108047
+1
In addition to filtering it would be useful to be able to see totals for players and the guild on a rolling basis in a way similar to the stats from GE.
I would separate out the various types of contribution and expense on different tabs so the guild can see what it is earning from GBs and donations weekly and spending on GE, siege costs etc week to week. This is not about being policing guild members but rather making it easier to plan and budget for guild activities...
In addition to filtering it would be useful to be able to see totals for players and the guild on a rolling basis in a way similar to the stats from GE.
I would separate out the various types of contribution and expense on different tabs so the guild can see what it is earning from GBs and donations weekly and spending on GE, siege costs etc week to week. This is not about being policing guild members but rather making it easier to plan and budget for guild activities...
DeletedUser99438
650 Pages of contributions to scroll through. In our guild 57 Members, in some 80. For every member, each good from each era is logged separate. It does not differentiate between contributions from Treasury GBs and ACTUAL Contributions to the treasury, there's a serious minus 1 just there.
From Treasury GBs alone 1 Member with all 3 Treasury GBs will log 15 events in 1 day. That's 855 events if all members have those 3 GBs. These aren't even needed, so that's 855 events ( or 85 and a half pages) of useless logs to trudge through everyday before you can assess anything useful. We dont' need a log for something we already possess data for. We need a log that shows that people are contributing the GE Costs so that they aren't costing the entire guild. Some guilds have a min Treasury Contributions as part of their requirements, we don't, but those that do, need a way to be able to assess this. Or we might like to just be able to thank those who are giving all the time. This system doesn't address these needs, far from it.
It should also have a tally function which would save space. When a member adds 50 RR for example and then later thinks they will add another 50, it won't show up as 2 events but will show as 1 event, ie: 100 RR Contributed. And TGBs should be a tally of their own but function similarly. And records should be retained for 1 week and then they can turn over for the start of a new week.
So in a guild where GvG, contributions and activity are important, adding this filter to this feature is extremely important so that it becomes usable. As it stands, Inno may as well not have bothered to implement this feature as it's time consuming and unusable....
A completely redundant feature.
Also yesterday we did have 690 so where in one day did we lose 50 pages of contributions? How can anything be assessed fairly with this system, even if one was willing to put the time in to use it, which by the way ... we're NOT
From Treasury GBs alone 1 Member with all 3 Treasury GBs will log 15 events in 1 day. That's 855 events if all members have those 3 GBs. These aren't even needed, so that's 855 events ( or 85 and a half pages) of useless logs to trudge through everyday before you can assess anything useful. We dont' need a log for something we already possess data for. We need a log that shows that people are contributing the GE Costs so that they aren't costing the entire guild. Some guilds have a min Treasury Contributions as part of their requirements, we don't, but those that do, need a way to be able to assess this. Or we might like to just be able to thank those who are giving all the time. This system doesn't address these needs, far from it.
It should also have a tally function which would save space. When a member adds 50 RR for example and then later thinks they will add another 50, it won't show up as 2 events but will show as 1 event, ie: 100 RR Contributed. And TGBs should be a tally of their own but function similarly. And records should be retained for 1 week and then they can turn over for the start of a new week.
So in a guild where GvG, contributions and activity are important, adding this filter to this feature is extremely important so that it becomes usable. As it stands, Inno may as well not have bothered to implement this feature as it's time consuming and unusable....
A completely redundant feature.
Also yesterday we did have 690 so where in one day did we lose 50 pages of contributions? How can anything be assessed fairly with this system, even if one was willing to put the time in to use it, which by the way ... we're NOT
Last edited by a moderator:
DeletedUser15501
+1, pretty obvious to everyone who plays and runs a guild that this needs to be implemented. As it is now this feature is of no use to anyone.
DeletedUser109385
I think this idea is quite good so +1
DeletedUser106505
Really really needs filters if I can use it at all as a guild leader..
Such a good idea..what a shame
Such a good idea..what a shame
DeletedUser109581
+1
DeletedUser101864
Great idea +1
DeletedUser
I find here two ideas but they both has point so +1
Denver Pyle
Master Corporal
+1
Also have the list in a format similar to message threads where you could copy and paste them it would help for leaders wanting to export the data into spreadsheets. Especially if you could scroll through the list instead of page by page, would make things so much simpler.
Also have the list in a format similar to message threads where you could copy and paste them it would help for leaders wanting to export the data into spreadsheets. Especially if you could scroll through the list instead of page by page, would make things so much simpler.
DeletedUser653
+1 to be able to see players donations that they make separate from all the GB etc would be very good and speed up a big manual job today
DeletedUser6838
So, what overtype meant by filter is: instead of generating a donated message on every goods type your GB adds to the list, it could take all the 5 goods into one single line and when someone donates goods by hand, also add up to 5 different goods types onto 1 line instead of generating a new line on each good in order to save the players from those dreadful page numbers.
+1 obviously.
+1 obviously
.
numbrcrunchr
Master Corporal
+1
DeletedUser103370
+1
DeletedUser
1+
DeletedUser
im a 1+ but can i ask is founders only aloud to see it or leaders as well, or everyone in the guild?Proposal: Add a filter system for Guild Contributions and make one entry per action.
Have you checked the forums for the same or similar idea: None
Reason: In my opinion we need filter system and it's too many entries per action.
Details: Add a filter system and one entry per action.
Visual Aids:
View attachment 11586
View attachment 11585
Balance/Abuse Prevention: N/A
DeletedUser110433
Can`t walk pass a decant idea.
+1
+1
DeletedUser16112
- Status