• Dear forum reader,
    To actively participate in our forum discussions or to start your own threads, in addition to your game account, you need a forum account. You can     REGISTER HERE!
    Please ensure a translation into English is provided if your post is not in English and to respect your fellow players when posting.
  • We are looking for you!
    Always wanted to join our Support or Forum Team? We are looking for enthusiastic moderators!
    Take a look at our recruitment page for more information and how you can apply:
    Apply
  • Forum Contests

    Won't you join us for out latest contest?
    You can check out the newest one here.

Forwarded: GE league -

  • Thread starter Thread starter DeletedUser116867
  • Start date Start date

Would you like to change a way of matching up guilds in GE to make it more competitive?

  • Total voters
    22
Status
Not open for further replies.
Can someone explain how GE currently works in regard to being placed 1. 2. and 3.

How are the Guilds matched up against eachother like eg.:

A guild with 70 members all participating in the GE (lets say 20% finish all levels and the remaining 80% all finish level 3).
vs
and a guild with 35 members all participating in the GE (lets say 20% finish all levels and the remaining 80% all finish level 3).

What determines who comes out on top ?.
 
Galladhorn said:
Can someone explain how GE currently works in regard to being placed 1. 2. and 3.

How are the Guilds matched up against eachother like eg.:

A guild with 70 members all participating in the GE (lets say 20% finish all levels and the remaining 80% all finish level 3).
vs
and a guild with 35 members all participating in the GE (lets say 20% finish all levels and the remaining 80% all finish level 3).

What determines who comes out on top ?.
Click to expand...
According to your example, it would be a tie.
Because it depends not on how many, but how far you go.
You could in theory win by having a one-person guild, then doing 64/64 for the trophy- every single time. Of course, you can’t participate with one...
 
Galladhorn said:
Can someone explain how GE currently works in regard to being placed 1. 2. and 3.
Click to expand...
the guilds who reaches it first gets the better place (like in GB: the place of people who donate the same is decided in the order they

Galladhorn said:
A guild with 70 members all participating in the GE (lets say 20% finish all levels and the remaining 80% all finish level 3).
vs
and a guild with 35 members all participating in the GE (lets say 20% finish all levels and the remaining 80% all finish level 3).

What determines who comes out on top ?.
Click to expand...
the guild which is finished first wins

Terrius said:
According to your example, it would be a tie.
Click to expand...
there is no tie


Terrius said:
Because it depends not on how many, but how far you go.
Click to expand...
and how fast

Terrius said:
You could in theory win by having a one-person guild, then doing 64/64 for the trophy- every single time. Of course, you can’t participate with one...
Click to expand...
but there are many 3 men guild out there doing championship every week with 133.3%



Terrius said:
For the prize, may I suggest a chest you can choose two items out of:
100 Diamonds
...
Click to expand...
no
suggesting a new / easier way to get diamonds is forbidden
 
and you need to read the rules first before posting any idea

then you wouldn't break it by suggesting getting diamonds as reward

:rolleyes:
 
and nice that you go after my mistake that was immediately fixed

but ignoring your fails which were pointed out in my long posting
 
Alright folks, let me get back to begining.
What i would like to know if this current GE format is good for you? If everyone agrees it ok, then no need to continiue this.
If you think there could be some change and there is space for improving it, i am open to discusion. Any suggestion is welcome, if we come up to something smart i can put it all togehter in new post and place it for voating.
 
Galladhorn said:
A guild with 70 members all participating in the GE (lets say 20% finish all levels and the remaining 80% all finish level 3).
vs
and a guild with 35 members all participating in the GE (lets say 20% finish all levels and the remaining 80% all finish level 3).
Click to expand...

Those are never matched up.

Terrius said:
According to your example, it would be a tie.
Because it depends not on how many, but how far you go.
You could in theory win by having a one-person guild, then doing 64/64 for the trophy- every single time. Of course, you can’t participate with one...
Click to expand...

There is no such thing as a tie and it does depend on how many go the distance.


Callisto the Mighty one said:
Alright folks, let me get back to begining.
What i would like to know if this current GE format is good for you? If everyone agrees it ok, then no need to continiue this.
If you think there could be some change and there is space for improving it, i am open to discusion. Any suggestion is welcome, if we come up to something smart i can put it all togehter in new post and place it for voating.
Click to expand...

As long as you do not get that guild ranking only comes about through GvG discussing this is useless.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Agent327 said:
Those are never matched up.



There is no such thing as a tie and it does depend on how many go the distance.



As long as you do not get that guild ranking only comes about through GvG discussing this is useless.
Click to expand...
Do you like current format of GE. Simple Yes or No?
 
Agent327 said:
Does it matter? Do I want your league? NO!

Way to many flaws in the idea. If you want suggestions on how to improve it, you should not have made a halfbaked proposal, but you should have started the discussion you want now.
Click to expand...
Ok man, calm your tension, have i said something to insult you to be so aggresive?
Its not halfbaked proposal, its baked, but i am open to make changes on it if necessary.
I come to an idea and placed it here, i am first time on forum and not quite shure what are the rules. Cant we discuss about it here?
If you dont like it, that is ok, vote for no and thats it. To be honest i am aware that idea will most likely fail, game go in, this is forgoten and thats it.
Dont be that kind of people who just wait for someone who suggest something to spit on it.
 
Galladhorn said:
How does it work? – are the Guilds matched up accordingly to numbers of guild members or how?
Click to expand...
Yes, by numbers of members. But i belive that should not be only condition as there is realy lack of uncertainty in race for week champion.
Example, my guild is always above 100%, even on realy easy week. When we get hard opponent then we go to 133.3%. So maximum.
What i am talking about is to somehow put more guilds with similar chance to win it. This realy dont have any sence and its quite boring to win every time with such huge diference.
 
Callisto the Mighty one said:
Yes, by numbers of members. But i belive that should not be only condition as there is realy lack of uncertainty in race for week champion.
Example, my guild is always above 100%, even on realy easy week. When we get hard opponent then we go to 133.3%. So maximum.
What i am talking about is to somehow put more guilds with similar chance to win it. This realy dont have any sence and its quite boring to win every time with such huge diference.
Click to expand...
All guilds already have a similar chance of winning but some are just not interested
 
Callisto the Mighty one said:
Ok man, calm your tension, have i said something to insult you to be so aggresive?
Its not halfbaked proposal, its baked, but i am open to make changes on it if necessary.
I come to an idea and placed it here, i am first time on forum and not quite shure what are the rules. Cant we discuss about it here?
If you dont like it, that is ok, vote for no and thats it. To be honest i am aware that idea will most likely fail, game go in, this is forgoten and thats it.
Dont be that kind of people who just wait for someone who suggest something to spit on it.
Click to expand...

You let GvG determine what guilds you meet in GE. How can that not be halfbaked?

Galladhorn said:
How does it work? – are the Guilds matched up accordingly to numbers of guild members or how?
Click to expand...

https://forum.en.forgeofempires.com/index.php?threads/guild-championships.32281/
 
Agent327 said:
You let GvG determine what guilds you meet in GE. How can that not be halfbaked?



https://forum.en.forgeofempires.com/index.php?threads/guild-championships.32281/
Click to expand...
You are missing the point here. It doesnt matter what determan which guilds will compete but quality of that competition. Quality is what i am talking about.
Lets talk football language. If Real Madrid is competing clubs from some bad 2nd leaguue, do you think they would be happy with that? No. They got quality league and championship league. So thats what i am trying to say, strong guilds vs strong guilds makes things more interesthing then current situation.
 
-1
I like how it is currently set up as the competing guilds have an equal chance of winning no matter where they are currently ranked in their world. It’s just most guilds dont really bother much with GE.

My guild also wins easily most week, but the weeks we have to compete makes it more exciting, I do agree with you there.

However, if we were to compete like that every week, a few people in our guild would not be able to do so as they don’t have the resources. When we have to give it everything, the other guild members do help out the ones that are struggling. If this were to happen each week, it would cause a strain on the guild as a whole.
 
Xenophon the Prophet 576 said:
-1
I like how it is currently set up as the competing guilds have an equal chance of winning no matter where they are currently ranked in their world. It’s just most guilds dont really bother much with GE.

My guild also wins easily most week, but the weeks we have to compete makes it more exciting, I do agree with you there.

However, if we were to compete like that every week, a few people in our guild would not be able to do so as they don’t have the resources. When we have to give it everything, the other guild members do help out the ones that are struggling. If this were to happen each week, it would cause a strain on the guild as a whole.
Click to expand...
Great you have wrote something like this.
Now why do most guilds dont bother with GE?
Obviously some change is needed.
Now to say something about end of your post.. if we were to compite like that every week, most of those strong guilds that can do 133.3 on hard week could not be able to do it every week. And then league would show which guild truly is the best. My guild has record of 113 gold, 16 silver and 3 bronze medals. And i dont remember when was the last time that we havent won gold. So most of this gold medals were won against guilds that havent had any chance to beat us. Real strenght of guild in GE would be shown if we would be put in same basket with guilds equally eager to win. League would required a bit if thinking and tactic, what matches to play with whole strength, and where you can relax a bit, depending on schedule.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top