New Idea: Event - Contests Journals about Guild Activity and Recruitment

Do you find usefull this idea/proposal ?

  • Yes

    Votes: 2 28.6%
  • Yes i would like to further improve it and specialise it before it gets forwarded

    Votes: 1 14.3%
  • No , this wouldn't help.

    Votes: 3 42.9%
  • No this could cause Unbalance - Abusal

    Votes: 1 14.3%

  • Total voters
    7

r21r

Second Lieutenant
Proposal:

Make Events on Forum, about Top 10 or Top 5 Guilds in every World with Rewards for the Journalists

Have you Checked the Ideas section for the same idea posted by someone else? Is this idea similar to one that has been previously suggested?

I gave look nothing similar

Reason:

The current recruitment status on both 2 worlds i am playing is pretty bad.
This could also improve the Quality and the Quantity of the Forum activity aswell

Details:

We could make Journals about top 5 trade Guilds - top 5 GvG Guilds - top 5 GBG Guilds with their moto and their purpose ofcurse.
This could help people who are in need of something particular and dont want to spend 2 weeks in each Guild untill they find something they really fit them
As long as all Guilds have in their Descriptions the same things, then what makes them Different ? Their Banner ?
A rating system for the Guilds that are offering the things that they are Describing they offer would make the whole thing more interesting
New Events so new rewards - Rating Systems so People can rate a Guild and help other Find the best to their Needs faster and ofcurse a new worthy Reason to become member in the forum.

Visual Aids:

Nope

Balance:

Strong Guilds will become Stronger but why should we , the solo players support Weak Guilds if we want to play more competitive ?

Abuse Prevention:

Guilds might lie about the real situation but as long as the forum is active the truth will shine in the end

Summary:

I noticed that Recruitment which is the most important thing in every Game that has Clans - Guilds - Teams in it, is at least bad on this forum.
This could help a lot the things around , give the power to people to Rate the Guilds by other facts than their current possition which might be depending only to their Alcatraz's or their Alliances with other Guilds and make the whole thing a Team up situation.

Any Feedback or idea added on mine is appreciated - I think i made it clear enough to be understood though
Cheers !
 
Last edited:

Vesiger

Monarch
I agree that all guilds basically tend to put the same thing in their descriptions, but I think the main distinguishing factor between most guilds is activity level.

I doubt the suggestion would do anything to affect guild recruitment, but it might conceivably add some interest to the forum...
 

Zamzara

I created a poll for testing, but this can be shared in one Guilds Recruitments thread per World in relation to the said guild under player's vote who have had actual experience with that guild. It's like playing a video game and rating it in regards to graphics, gameplay, movement, storyline, repetitive.

See for yourself, the vote can be selected to suit the player's experience. Only check what is relevant. This can't be abused by someone who hates another guild as it's been prevented with a yes/no under Recommendation. Not sure about it being abused though, probably IP recorded.

Oh, use Ad Blocker if you need to: https://linkto.run/p/MUQRIX1X
Link to poll results: https://linkto.run/r/MUQRIX1X
 
Last edited by a moderator:

r21r

Second Lieutenant
Another Reward could be some Extra friend invites, if this could be done ofc, this is also a cool reward and it will attract the older players to add their little something in the whole recruitment part.
+20 extra invites as reward wouldnt be an abuse
 

Agent327

Overlord
Another Reward could be some Extra friend invites, if this could be done ofc, this is also a cool reward and it will attract the older players to add their little something in the whole recruitment part.
+20 extra invites as reward wouldnt be an abuse
Yes it would. There is a reason for the number to be limited.