• Dear forum reader,
    To actively participate in our forum discussions or to start your own threads, in addition to your game account, you need a forum account. You can
    REGISTER HERE!
    Please ensure a translation into English is provided if your post is not in English and to respect your fellow players when posting.
  • We are looking for you!
    Always wanted to join our Support or Forum Team? We are looking for enthusiastic moderators!
    Take a look at our recruitment page for more information and how you can apply:
    Apply
  • Forum Contests

    Won't you join us for out latest contest?
    You can check out the newest one here.

Not a Bug: Aid&Black Tower

Status
Not open for further replies.

DeletedUser16876

It would appear that lower age buildings receive Aid over the new Black Tower in the priority list. For a relatively large special building offering multiple FPs/goods/medals when motivated would it not have been intended that a "Black Tower" should receive Aid "before" it is allocated to SoKs of multiple lower ages?
 

DeletedUser96901

SoK is first in the priority list
they will all get motivated before everything else

it would be nice if they change that list and put the buildings with 2 or more FP before them
 

DeletedUser111866

...or even allow players to have their (category-based, maybe?) priority lists for mo/po. I'd then put a pavilion high and bushes to lowest, and FINALLY be able to use them properly.

Hmm, an idea :)
 

DeletedUser16876

Not a bug.

Possibly not a bug but if a player has many SoKs then there is every chance Black Tower and and Manor House for example could always remain unaided. Given their size and that they give greater Rewards than SoKs it would seem more sensible to give them the same or higher priority.

Failing that you could just blame players for having too many SoKs or not enough aid coming in or just criticize their gameplay generally ! LoL Yes you can negate it by getting it manually motivated or use a kit but why should you need too? Fundamentally there is no reason why they shouldnt have the same or higher priority and while it may not effect many players or even effect those players all the time it does effect some players some of the time.

It would appear this is an unintended consequence (and its a low priority issue) but doesnt mean it shouldnt be fixed unless we contend that Black Tower and Manor house should rightfully be considered Inferior buildings to a SoK as the game currently does.
 

DeletedUser107476

so you say that the developers intentionally put better buildings behind worse buildings in the priority list :rolleyes:
I am saying they intentionally did not ask players which buildings should be in the priority list as HoF's would make it for a lot of players :P
 

DeletedUser110195

They shouldn't need to ask, it should be common sense that even a 4 year old possesses that 3 is greater than 1, never mind that the 3 also gives other things with it.
 

DeletedUser96901

I am saying they intentionally did not ask players which buildings should be in the priority list as HoF's would make it for a lot of players :P
actually it is on the priority list
only on the wrong position

logical would be: 3 FP > 2 FP > 1 FP

and not 1 FP > everything else

so you are saying they intentionally made 1 FP > 3 FP :rolleyes:

and what has HoF to do with 1 FP > 3 FP ?
HoF is not comparable because you can't compare complete different things
but you can compare same things: and FP are comparable with FP
 

DeletedUser107476

actually it is on the priority list
only on the wrong position

logical would be: 3 FP > 2 FP > 1 FP

and not 1 FP > everything else

so you are saying they intentionally made 1 FP > 3 FP :rolleyes:

and what has HoF to do with 1 FP > 3 FP ?
HoF is not comparable because you can't compare complete different things
but you can compare same things: and FP are comparable with FP
Actually FP is not comparable to FP unless you work out per square what they produce. Just because a building produces more does not make it more efficient. A Black Tower is 20 squares so divide that by the 3 fp it produces means it takes 6.666 squares to produce 1 fp. Now a Sok is 4 squares so divide that by that by the 1 fp it produces and it means it takes 4 squares for it to produce 1 fp. Therefore if we are basing this on fp alone then the SoK should be ahead of the Black Tower.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeletedUser96901

Actually FP is not comparable to FP
really ?
3 FP > 1 FP

everybody (except you) can compare that

A Black Tower is 20 squares so divide that by the 3 fp it produces means it takes 6.666 squares to produce 1 fp. Now a Sok is 4 squares so divide that by that by the 1 fp it produces and it means it takes 4 squares for it to produce 1 fp. Therefore if we are basing this on fp alone then the SoK should be ahead of the Black Tower.
please start thinking

we don't compare the square efficiency
we compare aid efficiency

one aid of the black tower is worth 3 FP (+ goods,...)
one aid of one SoK is worth 1 FP

so if we are basing on FP the Black Tower has the highest FP per aid efficiency

therefore the Black Tower MUST be first in the list

and everybody who don't understand that is an idiot (sorry if that applies to you)

Just because a building produces more does not make it more efficient.
actually it makes the aid more efficient
and that is all that matters

are you still saying aiding one SoK is more efficient than aiding one Black Tower ?
 

DeletedUser96901

and let me repeat it (for the case you did not understand the previous posting)
we compare real FPs: the thing which you have in the bar after you collected

3 is more than 2
and 2 is more than one

:rolleyes:

everybody can compare that
 

DeletedUser107476

does that matter ?

can you do more with one FP which came from 4 squares than with one FP which came from 6 squares

:rolleyes:
You can if you have more than 3 sok's compared with 1 Black Tower which a lot players do. Remember those 3 Sok's only take up 12 squares compared to 20 for Black Tower.
 

DeletedUser96901

You can if you have more than 3 sok's compared with 1 Black Tower which a lot players do. Remember those 3 Sok's only take up 12 squares compared to 20 for Black Tower.
if you get one aid do you really want it one the SoK ?

remember
one FP is less than 3 FP

:rolleyes:

so still don't matter how many squares each building has :rolleyes:
 

DeletedUser96901

then start a thread for that and discuss that there

here we talk about aiding Black Tower compared to SoK
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top